Smithey Ironware Cookware Review — An Expert’s In-Depth Look at Artisan Craftsmanship

ribbon
Get Free Shipping On Your Purchases

Get Free Shipping On Your Purchases

Get Free Shipping On Your Purchases
SEASONED
SHOW COUPON
On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Father's Day! Get Free Mighty Spatula With Any Order Over $150+

    Father’s Day! Get Free Mighty Spatula With Any Order Over $150+

    Father's Day! Get Free Mighty Spatula With Any Order Over $150+
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Signup & Unlock Free Engraving On Your First Order

    Signup & Unlock Free Engraving On Your First Order

    Signup & Unlock Free Engraving On Your First Order
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Shop Our Best Sellers Collection Starting As Low As $30

    Shop Our Best Sellers Collection Starting As Low As $30

    Shop Our Best Sellers Collection Starting As Low As $30
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Shop Our Sets Starting From $200

    Shop Our Sets Starting From $200

    Shop Our Sets Starting From $200
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Checkout Our Carbon Steel Collection Starts From $200

    Checkout Our Carbon Steel Collection Starts From $200

    Checkout Our Carbon Steel Collection Starts From $200
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Explore Our Cast Iron Collection Starts As Low As $85

    Explore Our Cast Iron Collection Starts As Low As $85

    Explore Our Cast Iron Collection Starts As Low As $85
    ACTIVATE DEAL
    On Going Offer
  • It Works 100% Success It Doesn’t
  • Smithey Ironware Featured Image

    When you think of timeless, heirloom-quality cookware, Smithey Ironware is a true champion in a world where pots and pans are increasingly mass-produced. Founded in Charleston, South Carolina, Smithey blends traditional metalworking techniques with modern functionality to create versatile, durable cookware that performs reliably under heavy use and lasts for generations.

    The Smithey team is comprised of passionate designers, blacksmiths, metalworkers, and chefs, all with a deep understanding of what makes cookware truly exceptional. Each piece is hand-forged, finished with a silky smooth finish, and designed to be a lifelong companion in your kitchen—a tool that evolves with your culinary skills.

    Pros
    ✔️Durable, heirloom-caliber craftsmanship
    ✔️Exceptional, even-heat retention for perfect sears and rich flavor
    ✔️Versatile — can move from stove to oven, grill, or even campfire
    ✔️Naturally nonstick when well-seasoned
    ✔️Beautiful, polished finish — a blend of form and functionality
    ✔️Lifetime warranty against defects in materials or workmanship
    ✔️Support for small, USA-based metalworking enterprise
    Cons
    ✖️ Requires careful maintenance (clean and oil after each use)
    ✖️ Higher price point than mass-produced cookware
    ✖️ Heavier — may be tiring for some, especially during extensive cooking sessions
    ✖️ May take time to grow a strong, nonstick patina

    🍳 Detailed Product Review

    🔥 1️⃣ No. 10 Flat Top Griddle

    Technical Specs:
      • Material: Cast iron

      • Diameter: 10 inches

      • Thickness: 0.25 inch (6.35 mm)

      • Finish: Machine-polished; flaxseed oil-seasoned

      • Handle: Loop handle for convenient grip

    Performance:

    This flat-top griddle is ideal for searing at high temperatures and evenly cooking pancakes, burgers, flatbreads, or even grilled sandwiches.

    The thick base ensures a constant temperature and provides rich colors and textures in every meal.

    This versatile piece moves elegantly from the stove to the grill or even the oven.

    🍳 2️⃣ No. 11 Deep Skillet

    Technical Specs:
      • Material: Cast iron

      • Diameter: 11 inches

      • Depth: 2.5 inches

      • Thickness: 0.3 inch (7.62 mm)

      • Finish: Machine-polished; flaxseed oil-seasoned

      • Handle: Extra-long handle + helper grip for stability

    Performance:

    Deep enough for frying, searing thick steaks, preparing hearty frittatas, or even baking cornbread right in the pan.

    The excellent heat retention ensures rich, even coloring without the need for high temperatures, saving energy while producing restaurant-quality food.

    🍲 5.5 Qt Dutch Oven

    Technical Specs:
      • Material: Cast iron

      • Capacity: 5.5 quarts

      • Thickness: 0.3 inch (7.62 mm)

      • Finish: Machine-polished; flaxseed oil-seasoned

      • Lid: Heavy, tight-fitting, matching cast iron lid

    Performance:

    The Smithey Dutch Oven is a real workhorse in the kitchen – perfect for slow cooking stews, chili, braised dishes or artisan bread.

    The thick, heavy lid helps retain steam, ensuring tender, rich, and flavorful food.

    It maintains temperature exceptionally well and delivers a depth of flavor that is difficult to achieve with modern materials.

    🥢 Carbon Steel Wok

    Technical Specs:
      • Material: Hand-forged carbon steel

      • Diameter: 12 inches (with flat base)

      • Thickness: 0.088 inch (2-3 mm)

      • Finish: Seasoned through high-heat process

      • Handle: Traditional metal handle for strong grip

    Performance:

    Fast, responsive, lightweight – this appliance is designed for high-temperature, high-energy cooking.

    The flat base ensures stability on the stovetop, while the incline allows ingredients to glide easily while preserving their structure and color – perfect for stir-frying, deep-frying, or quick cooking.

    With continued use, the surface develops a rich, natural non-stick patina.

    🥘 Carbon Steel Paella Pan

    Technical Specs:
        • Material: Hand-forged carbon steel

        • Diameter: 13 inches

        • Thickness: 0.088 inch (2-3 mm)

        • Finish: Seasoned through high-heat process

        • Handles: Durable side handles for easy transfer

    Performance:

    Whether you’re cooking paella or risotto, or sautéing large quantities of vegetables, this paella pan’s wide, shallow design can withstand heavy use—perfect for developing a rich socarrat (crispy base) while preserving texture and flavor.

    Excellent for use on the stove and in the oven.

    🍳 Smithey’s Commitment to Quality — An Artisan’s Promise 🍳

    The Smithey team places the utmost importance on craftsmanship—honoring traditional methods while embracing modern innovations. Each piece is meticulously crafted by skilled blacksmiths who pay attention to every detail—from texture to balance. The result: heavy, sophisticated cookware that will last for generations.

    📦 Shipping Policy 📦

    Smithey ships within the US and Canada directly from his workshop in Charleston.

      • Standard shipping typically takes 5–10 business days.
      • Expedited shipping is available for an additional charge.
      • All products are carefully packaged to prevent damage during transit.
      • Standard shipping is free on orders over $100—an added benefit for larger orders.

    🔁 Return Policy 🔁

    Smithey stands behind the quality of its products and your satisfaction.

      • Customers may return or exchange their cookware within 30 days of delivery in new, unused condition.
      • A restocking fee may apply for opened or used products.
      • Return shipments are the customer’s responsibility.
      • All returns must be processed through Smithey Customer Service.
      • Refunds are typically processed within 5–10 business days of the item being received in our warehouse.

    🛡 Warranty Details 🛡

    Smithey offers a lifetime warranty against defects in materials and workmanship – a testament to the company’s confidence in its own manufacturing standards.

    Damage caused by neglect, misuse, or normal wear and tear is not covered by the warranty, but the team is always available to assist with repairs or reseasoning if needed.

    ❓ FAQs ❓

    Q: Are Smithey products heavy to handle?
    ✅ Cast iron is heavy — that’s a big part of its ability to retain and evenly distribute heat — but their handles are designed for balance and ease of grip.

     

    Q: Are Smithey products induction-safe?
    ✅ All Smithey cookware — cast iron or carbon steel — is induction-safe due to its magnetic base.

     

    Q: How should I care for my Smithey cookware?
    ✅ Always hand wash with warm water and a stiff brush (without soap).
    ✅ Dry immediately and apply a light layer of oil to aid in preserving its nonstick surface.
    ✅ Season regularly for maximum performance.

     

    Q: Do Smithey products come pre-seasoned?
    ✅ All Smithey cookware is pre-seasoned with flaxseed oil — it’s ready to use upon delivery, although additional seasoning over time will further improve its nonstick properties.

    🔹 Smithey vs. Competition 🔹

    Compared to many mass-produced, cheaper cast iron brands (like Lodge) or renowned designer companies (like Le Creuset or Staub), Smithey is right on the money:

      • Higher quality than Lodge: Smithey’s surface is silky smooth (finished and polished), resulting in less sticking and a more refined cooking experience.
      • More durable and versatile than Staub/Le Creuset: While their enameled counterparts are practical and stylish, Smithey’s raw cast iron excels at high temperatures and develops a rich, natural non-stick patina with regular use.
      • Handcrafted and in small batches: This ensures greater control, care, and character—giving each piece a unique, artisanal touch.

    🔹 Final Verdict 🔹

    Smithey Ironware represents a remarkable combination of craftsmanship and functionality—honoring traditional metalworking while meeting the demands of modern cooking. While the heavy, thick, and traditional design may not be to everyone’s taste, Smithey is a strong choice for those who appreciate a tool that works well and ages gracefully.

    This is an investment in your cooking future—a set of pots, pans, and a casserole dish that will allow you to create rich, sophisticated meals today and for generations to come.