A note before we start: this article is about a consumer product, not medical advice. If you have symptoms that worry you, a GP or a registered dietitian is the right first stop, and nothing here should replace that.
The short version, before you scroll
YorkTest is a genuine British laboratory, operating since 1998 from a real site in York, with private equity behind it and 4.7 out of 5 from 3,274 Trustpilot reviewers. The customer experience is good. The problem is the science underneath the flagship product. The food intolerance test measures IgG antibodies, and the British Dietetic Association, the American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology and the Choosing Wisely material published on the BSACI’s own site all say the same thing: IgG antibodies to food are found in healthy people without any intolerance. The advertising regulator has upheld complaints against YorkTest twice, nine years apart.
Quick facts
|
|
Fayes Homestyle Score | 5.0 / 10 |
What it sells | Finger-prick home test kits posted back to a York lab. Food intolerance, food allergy, gut microbiome, hormones, general health panels |
Flagship price | Premium Food Intolerance Test at £120, advertised down from £199. Junior test £113. Food Allergy Test £119 |
What the intolerance test measures | Food-specific IgG antibodies, across all four subclasses IgG1 to IgG4 |
Company | YorkTest Laboratories Limited, incorporated 27 May 1998, based in Huntington, York |
Ownership | Private equity. An £8.6m management buyout in July 2017, then a £10m NVM Private Equity investment completed 26 July 2022 |
Trustpilot | 4.7 out of 5 from 3,274 reviews. 82 percent five star, 7 percent one star |
Regulatory record | Two upheld ASA rulings, in 2012 and 2021, plus an older 2007 ruling |
What does the test actually measure?
This is the whole article in one paragraph, so it is worth getting right.
Your immune system makes several classes of antibody. IgE is the one involved in true food allergy, the kind that causes hives, swelling and anaphylaxis. IgG is a different class entirely, and it is what the YorkTest Premium and Junior intolerance tests measure. YorkTest specifically says it measures all four IgG subclasses, IgG1 through IgG4, rather than IgG4 alone.
That distinction matters more than it sounds, and it is the one place where YorkTest has a genuine argument. The most-cited scientific position paper against this kind of testing is a 2008 European task force report whose title is literally that testing for IgG4 against foods is not recommended as a diagnostic tool. YorkTest can reasonably say that paper is about IgG4 specifically and not about what it sells.
The trouble is that the broader professional statements are not limited to IgG4.
What do the dietitians and allergy bodies actually say?
We went to the source documents rather than summaries, because this gets misquoted constantly in both directions.
- The British Dietetic Association, in its food allergy and intolerance testing resource, states that IgG food antibody testing claims an increase in IgG to a certain food indicates intolerance, and then says this is not reliable, because IgG antibodies to food are found in all healthy people without food allergies. On commercial tests generally it says they are not scientifically validated and can often recommend excluding a large number of foods unnecessarily.
- The American Academy of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology says the test has never been scientifically proven to be able to accomplish what it reports to do, that the presence of IgG is likely a normal response of the immune system to food exposure, and that higher levels of IgG4 to foods may simply be associated with tolerance to those foods.
- A Choosing Wisely document published on the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology’s website states that the presence of IgG antibodies does not indicate an allergy or intolerance to a specific food, and that IgG antibodies to food are formed in all healthy asymptomatic people. We should be precise here: this is a document hosted by BSACI rather than clearly badged as an official position statement.
- The advertising regulator’s own guidance states that it has not seen convincing evidence that food allergy and intolerance test kits used alone are effective.
Read those together and the position is consistent. The objection is not that YorkTest’s lab is sloppy. It is that the thing being measured is, according to these bodies, something everybody has.
One gap worth naming honestly: we could not retrieve the exact current NHS wording on home intolerance testing in this pass. What is documented second-hand is that the advertising regulator’s guidance states the NHS does not recommend home food intolerance tests, and that a 2021 ruling recorded YorkTest’s definition of food intolerance as differing from the NHS’s.
The two ASA rulings, in detail
This is the hardest evidence in the whole review, because it is a regulator making a finding rather than a commentator expressing a view.
2012: testimonials and efficacy claims
A direct mailing for a product called FoodScan carried customer testimonials covering hyperactivity, tiredness, weight problems and itchy skin. The ASA upheld the complaint on both counts. YorkTest could not evidence that the testimonials were genuine, including ones implying that children of four and five were reading food labels and managing their own diets. It also could not substantiate efficacy claims for weight problems, arthritis and tiredness. The advertisement was withdrawn.
2021: migraine, depression, and the definition of intolerance
A television advertisement and the website were both ruled against in June 2021, and this one is more significant.
First, claims that the YorkTest programme could help with migraine and depression were found unsubstantiated. The ASA judged the submitted studies too weak on design, sample size or bias, found the depression evidence did not show an elimination diet reduced disease severity, and specifically dismissed an editorial written by a YorkTest staff member on the grounds that it was not research.
Second, and more fundamentally, the ASA addressed the statement that YorkTest defines food intolerance as a food-specific IgG reaction. It noted this definition differed from the NHS’s, and that the multi-step nature of the programme was not made clear. YorkTest was told not to imply that its IgG test, either alone or combined with further tests and an elimination diet, can diagnose specific food intolerances, and not to claim its elimination diet can alleviate migraine or depression.
There is also an older 2007 ruling cited in the regulator’s guidance, on the point that IgE results cannot be described as clinically validated.
Beyond the ASA, we found no MHRA action, no competition authority action and no lawsuits.
What evidence does YorkTest offer for itself?
Four things, and it is worth being clear about what each one is.
Claim | What it actually is |
98 percent reproducibility | No study is referenced on the page. Reproducibility means the test gives the same answer twice, not that the answer means anything |
82 percent reported a positive impact on health and wellbeing | A customer satisfaction survey conducted in 2021 with 565 respondents. Not a clinical trial, no control group |
Customer case studies and testimonials | The category the 2012 ASA ruling was specifically about |
A Scientific Research section on the site | Contents not reviewed in this pass. In the 2021 case some randomised trials on IBS and IBD gave partial support, but the ASA judged the body of evidence insufficient |
Reproducibility deserves a line of its own because it sounds like validation and is not. A bathroom scale that reads 12 kilograms every time you stand on it is highly reproducible and completely wrong.
Reproducibility deserves a line of its own because it sounds like validation and is not. A bathroom scale that reads 12 kilograms every time you stand on it is highly reproducible and completely wrong. Reproducibility tells you the lab is consistent. It tells you nothing about whether a raised IgG level means you should stop eating bread.
What about the accreditation badges?
YorkTest displays several, and they are not all what a buyer might assume.
- ISO 13485 is a medical-device quality management standard. It certifies how a company runs its processes, not whether a particular test is clinically valid.
- An IBMS approval for pre-registration training laboratories is an approval to train biomedical scientists. It is a credit to the lab as a workplace and says nothing about test validity.
- Compliance with the older EU Medical Device and IVD Directives is cited, rather than a CE or UKCA mark, which we did not find claimed.
- A UKAS-accredited laboratory claim appears in the Premium test FAQ. We did not verify it against a UKAS schedule, and we would not repeat it as established without doing so.
- ISO 15189, which is the actual medical-laboratory competence standard, was not found and is not claimed.
None of that means the lab is bad. It means the badges on display are quality-management and training credentials presented in a way that reads like clinical validation.
To its credit, YorkTest does not claim to diagnose allergies
This deserves saying plainly, because a lot of criticism in this space is aimed at companies that do overclaim, and YorkTest is more careful than most.
The Premium test page states that results cannot be used to diagnose, treat or cure food intolerances, that they are for informational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice, and that the tests are not allergy, lactose intolerance or coeliac tests. The FAQ distinguishes IgE-mediated allergy from the antibodies being measured. YorkTest also sells a separate IgE-based Food Allergy Test, which rests on a biomarker nobody disputes.
The one claim to treat sceptically is the assertion that the programme is consistent with NHS guidance, given that a regulator specifically recorded in 2021 that YorkTest’s definition of food intolerance differed from the NHS’s.
So why are the reviews so good?
Because the reviews are measuring a different thing from the science. Trustpilot shows 4.7 out of 5 from 3,274 reviews, with 82 percent at five stars and 7 percent at one star. Turnaround is around seven days. You get a traffic-light report ranking foods as high, borderline or normal, a nutritional support guide, and access to a nutritional consultation.
“Only one one-star review was visible on the page we read, concerning result accuracy, which is not enough to establish a complaint pattern either way” — Research limitation, stated so readers can weigh it rather than assume
That is a well-run consumer service, and the ratings reflect it. But a satisfaction score answers the question did I have a good experience, not the question did this tell me something true. People who cut out several foods and feel better will rate the test highly, and an elimination diet undertaken attentively tends to make people feel better regardless of what prompted it, because they eat less processed food and pay closer attention. That is a real benefit. It is just not evidence that the IgG reading identified the culprit.
Note too that the site runs a permanent was-£199-now-£120 discount, which makes the £199 reference price hard to take at face value.
Who should buy it, and who should walk away
Add Your It might be worth it if you want a structured starting point and you know what you are buyingText Here
If you have vague gut symptoms, you have already ruled out coeliac disease and anything serious with a GP, and you want a structured 200-food elimination framework with a nutritionist conversation attached rather than guessing in the dark, £120 buys you that. Just understand that the value you are getting is the structure and the support, not a diagnosis.
Walk away if you are expecting a diagnosis
The test cannot diagnose a food intolerance, YorkTest itself says so, and a regulator told it in 2021 not to imply otherwise. If you want to know whether you have coeliac disease, lactose intolerance or a true food allergy, this is not the test for any of them.
Walk away if you are buying it for a child without a professional involved
The Junior test covers 100-plus items for children aged two and up. Removing a large number of foods from a growing child’s diet on the basis of a biomarker that the British Dietetic Association says is present in all healthy people is the scenario that worries dietitians most. If you go down this road with a child, do it with a registered dietitian alongside you.
If you buy one YorkTest product, buy this one
The Food Allergy Test at £119, if allergy is actually what you are worried about. It measures IgE, which is the biomarker the whole allergy field agrees on, across 23 food and 19 environmental allergens. It is the one product in the range whose underlying science is not contested. The Premium intolerance test at £120 is the better-known product and the one this review is mostly about, and it is the one where you are paying for structure rather than for an answer.
Questions people actually ask
Is the YorkTest food intolerance test accurate?
It appears to be consistent, which is a different thing. YorkTest claims 98 percent reproducibility, meaning the lab gets the same reading twice. Whether the reading means anything is the contested part: the British Dietetic Association, the AAAAI and Choosing Wisely guidance all state that IgG antibodies to food are found in healthy people without intolerance.
Is YorkTest a scam?
Add Your Heading Text Here
No, and it would be unfair to call it one. It is a real laboratory, incorporated in 1998, operating from a physical site in York with private equity investment behind it, and it carries clear disclaimers saying its results cannot diagnose anything. The criticism is about the scientific basis of the test, not about whether the company exists or delivers what it sells.
Has YorkTest been in trouble with the ASA?
Yes, twice on the record. In 2012 over unevidenced testimonials and efficacy claims for weight problems, arthritis and tiredness. In 2021 over unsubstantiated migraine and depression claims, and for implying its IgG test could diagnose specific food intolerances. Both complaints were upheld. An older 2007 ruling also exists.
Does the NHS recommend food intolerance tests?
The advertising regulator’s published guidance states that the NHS does not recommend home food intolerance tests, and a 2021 ruling recorded that YorkTest’s definition of food intolerance differs from the NHS’s. We could not retrieve the current NHS page wording directly, so check nhs.uk yourself before relying on any quoted version of it.
What is the difference between the YorkTest allergy and intolerance tests?
The Food Allergy Test measures IgE, the antibody involved in true allergic reactions, and that science is uncontested. The Premium and Junior intolerance tests measure IgG antibodies across all four subclasses, and that is the test professional bodies reject as a diagnostic tool.
Fayes Homestyle Scorecard
|
|
Scientific basis of the flagship test | 2.0 / 10 |
Laboratory credibility and transparency | 6.5 / 10 |
Honesty of disclaimers | 7.0 / 10 |
Advertising record | 3.0 / 10 |
Customer experience | 8.5 / 10 |
Value for money | 4.0 / 10 |
Overall Fayes Homestyle Score | 5.0 / 10 |
The bottom line
YorkTest is a well-run company selling a product the relevant professions do not accept. Those two things are both true and most reviews pick one and ignore the other.
On the credit side: a real laboratory trading since 1998, serious investment behind it, 4.7 out of 5 from 3,274 reviewers, a seven-day turnaround, a structured report, nutritionist support, and disclaimers that explicitly say the results cannot diagnose or treat anything. It measures all four IgG subclasses rather than IgG4 alone, which does blunt the single most-cited criticism. It also sells a properly grounded IgE allergy test.
On the other side: the British Dietetic Association says IgG food antibody testing is not reliable because those antibodies are found in all healthy people, the AAAAI says the test has never been scientifically proven to do what it reports to do, and Choosing Wisely material on the BSACI site says the same. The supporting evidence YorkTest offers is a reproducibility figure with no citation and a 565-person customer satisfaction survey. And the advertising regulator has upheld complaints twice, in 2012 and 2021, the second time instructing the company not to imply its test can diagnose specific food intolerances.
If you buy it, buy it knowing you are paying £120 for a structured elimination framework and some professional support, which has real value for some people. Do not buy it believing it will tell you what is wrong with you, because the company itself says it cannot. And if your symptoms are persistent or severe, that conversation belongs with a GP or a registered dietitian first.

What do you think?